Define the benchmark
In a common US futures comparison, the diesel crack uses NY Harbor ULSD and WTI crude. Specify both benchmarks and delivery months. A different regional diesel assessment or crude grade represents a different relationship and should not be silently substituted.
The simple 1:1 calculation, with ULSD in dollars per gallon and crude in dollars per barrel, is ULSD × 42 − crude.
A hypothetical calculation
At ULSD $2.40/gallon and WTI $75/barrel, the converted product value is $100.80/barrel. The difference is $25.80/barrel. If ULSD rises to $2.45 while WTI rises to $77, the new difference is $25.90: only $0.10 wider despite increases in both prices.
This example demonstrates relative movement. A view that diesel prices will rise is not sufficient to establish that the diesel crack will widen; the crude leg may rise faster after conversion.
Read each leg
When reviewing a sharp change, compare product and crude returns over the same interval. Check whether contract rolls or differing timestamps explain part of the movement. Then examine relevant inventory and refinery information to develop, rather than assume, an explanation.
For a seasonal study, maintain the same month rule across years. A continuous nearest-contract series may introduce roll changes unrelated to the relationship you want to study.
Keep three measures separate
The current crack level, the change in that level and actual trading P&L are different measures. P&L depends on direction, sizing and execution. The crack level also excludes the full cost structure of physical refining.
Use the same unit checks for every data source. A feed in cents per gallon and a feed in dollars per gallon differ by a factor of 100 before the barrel conversion.
Why a diesel price forecast is not a crack forecast
The diesel crack measures a difference after unit conversion. An outright price forecast concerns only one leg. To see the distinction, keep the initial hypothetical values of 2.40 dollars per gallon for ULSD and 75 dollars per barrel for crude. If ULSD rises to 2.50 while crude rises to 80, the crack becomes 25 dollars per barrel. Diesel has become more expensive, but the crack has narrowed from 25.80.
Now consider falling prices. If ULSD falls to 2.35 and crude falls to 70, the crack becomes 28.70 dollars per barrel. The product is cheaper, but its value relative to crude has increased. These are invented scenarios that illustrate the calculation, not forecasts or statements about current market conditions.
When writing a research hypothesis, describe the relative change you are investigating. A statement such as product value may strengthen compared with this crude benchmark is more precise than diesel may rise. The next step is to identify which observations would support or contradict that hypothesis and whether the selected contract months express it.
Decompose changes before explaining their cause
For two observations using the same dated contracts, the change in the crack equals forty-two times the change in the ULSD quote minus the change in the crude quote. This identity provides a simple attribution table. Show the converted product contribution, the crude contribution and their total. Reconcile the total with the change in the chart before adding an economic explanation.
If the chart and attribution disagree, inspect the inputs first. A contract transition, a different settlement date or a cents-versus-dollars mistake can explain the difference. Check that both observations represent the same units and benchmarks. If one leg is stale while the other has updated, the apparent relative move may partly reflect the timing mismatch.
After reconciliation, examine evidence relevant to each leg. Product inventories may help frame a hypothesis about distillate conditions, while crude information addresses a different part of the relationship. A single statistic is rarely a complete causal explanation. The EIA’s product balance discussion is a useful starting point for distinguishing inventory and demand context from the arithmetic of a crack quote.
Translate the move into an explicitly sized example
Assume an illustrative position with equal one-thousand-barrel-equivalent exposure in the product and crude legs. A ten-cent-per-barrel widening corresponds to a one-hundred-dollar gross gain for a long product-minus-crude position. The same change produces a gross loss for the opposite position. The example depends on the stated exposure and excludes fees and slippage.
Check the conversion another way using the earlier move from 2.40 to 2.45 in ULSD and 75 to 77 in crude. The product’s converted increase is 2.10 dollars per barrel, while crude increases by two dollars. The net is ten cents per barrel. Multiplying each leg’s change by the same barrel-equivalent exposure gives the same net result.
Do not treat a lower margin requirement, when available, as evidence of a smaller possible loss. Margin and profit-and-loss sensitivity measure different things, and actual requirements depend on the contracts, account and current rules. Keep the monetary sensitivity calculation separate from any broker-specific funding information. The guide’s numerical example does not establish a suitable position size.
Distinguish benchmark exposure from local physical exposure
The phrase diesel crack can refer to different regional product and crude combinations. A chart based on NY Harbor ULSD and WTI is not automatically comparable with a local physical diesel assessment against another crude benchmark. Product quality, delivery location, timing and quotation conventions can differ. Begin comparisons by listing these definitions rather than treating the shared label as proof of equivalence.
A physical business can experience a change in its local selling price relative to the futures benchmark even when the benchmark crack stays constant. The same issue can affect the cost of its crude input. Such basis differences are part of the gap between a simplified futures relationship and a realized physical margin. They cannot be recovered from the two benchmark prices alone.
For a research chart, consistency is the immediate priority. Use the same benchmarks and month convention across the historical window. If you intentionally change either, start a separately labeled comparison. This helps avoid interpreting a construction change as a seasonal opportunity or as an error in another provider’s chart.
Design a focused historical comparison
Choose one delivery-month rule and one holding window before reviewing outcomes. Inspect individual years and compare the product and crude contributions during losing windows as well as winning ones. Then ask whether the finding survives a modest change in the observation window. Record missing observations, roll conventions and costs alongside the result. For a broader basket that combines gasoline and distillate, continue with the 3:2:1 calculation; its weights answer a different relative-value question.
When presenting the study, include one complete example of a losing observation as well as a profitable one. Show the same fields for both: product entry and exit, crude entry and exit, converted changes and the resulting crack change. This prevents the explanation from depending on a favorable example and makes the sign convention easier to verify. A reader should be able to reproduce either outcome with the same formula, without changing the interpretation when the direction becomes unfavorable.
Continue your research
Inspect the evidence behind a spread idea
Explore the available markets, compare seasonal windows and review historical outcomes.
Open FuturesSpreadFutures trading involves substantial risk. Educational examples are hypothetical. Historical patterns and backtests do not guarantee future results. Check current market coverage and access terms in the product.
Research content version 2026.09.29.1